by Bob » Wed Oct 31, 2012 10:44 am
I got this e-mail from Steve Lyman this morning (I happen to have the One-Way versions):
The Recent 3-Album 2-CD Re-Issue of SRC's Capitol Releases
The Amazon reviewer was quite correct. It does seem to be the same audio-flaw, which went wholly unnoticed with the 2001 British "Black Sheep" release (that one done by former Bam Caruso guy Phil Smee). It seems that somehow Capitol has remastered and stored the SRC catalogue, without knowing that the 1st and 2nd album contents were mistakenly done in mono from the stereo source (there was no mono mix done originally). The new CD release is supposedly remastered in 2012 by Andrew Thompson at Sound Performance in London, so he was probably not listening carefully enough to realize that the only stereo tracks were those from the "Traveler's Tale" album. I find this quite appalling, not for myself, but particularly for those who spent as much as 25 dollars to have an accurate reproduction of SRC's entire Capitol catalogue. When a mono mix is made from a stereo source, aside from losing the left-to-right stereo imaging, it also creates phasing problems whereby certain frequencies may nearly disappear. I've got to say that the only really reliable CDs seem to be the One Way versions from 1992-1993. These remasters (of 2001 & 2012) are fine, if all one wishes to hear is that third album's material, but for most SRC fans, it is the material from 1968 & 1969 which is most desirable. As best I can recall, the only thing originally mixed in mono was the single version of "Black Sheep," because at that time, most singles (geared for AM radio) were mixed in mono. I think that John Rhys did both a mono mix and a stereo mix on that later shortened version of our first single. But when it was released (at the end of 1968), I am quite sure that Capitol just did it with the stereo mix, as by then 45RPM singles were becoming more commonplace.
BGOCD1051 SRC "SRC * Milestones * Traveler's Tale" digitally re-mastered
Beat Goes On Records, 7 Andrews Street North, Bury St. Edmunds, Suffolk IP33 1TZ, England
sincerely,
Steve
SRC aficionado since 1968